VPN for Devices

Walkthrough

Does a VPN on a router cause Strict NAT on PlayStation and Xbox

Yes, a VPN on a router can make the NAT on a PS5 or Xbox strict. VPN Advisor explains this through double NAT. VPNMine clarifies that the console ends up behind the tunnel's NAT in addition to the router's NAT, so the connection usually becomes stricter. Check the NAT type on the console first with the VPN enabled, then with it disabled. If Strict appears only with the VPN, enable NAT control on the VPN server side: Moderate NAT mode or port forwarding through the tunnel, if the provider supports it. Local UPnP is not enough for this. Such a check requires a console, access to the router panel and a VPN account.

4 minutesRevised From VPN for Devices

These methods have limitations. According to NAT Checker, Proton VPN does not allow Moderate NAT and NAT-PMP to be enabled at the same time. The result on a PS5 also depends on the connection setup: through a router or through a PC hotspot. Top10VPN describes obtaining Moderate on an Xbox via a Windows 10 or 11 hotspot. NAT Checker links the result to the NAT capabilities of the VPN server itself.

Identify where Strict appears and choose an action

Inside the tunnel, the NAT type is set by the VPN server. As NAT Checker writes, UPnP and port forwarding on the home router no longer affect this traffic. The action is therefore chosen based on two factors: whether Strict appears only with the VPN, and whether the VPN provider can manage NAT.

SituationActionSource
Strict only with the VPN enabledEnable the server's NAT setting, for example Moderate NAT on Proton VPN Plus in a supported router profileNAT Checker
An open port is needed with the VPN enabledUse forwarding through the tunnel that the provider supportsVPNMine, NAT Checker
Strict remains without the VPNCheck for CGNAT; if present, request a public IP address from the provider or use a VPN with managed NATNAT Checker

Find the cause and change the NAT configuration

  1. Connect the console to the router the way you usually play (cable or Wi-Fi). Run the network test and note the NAT type.
  2. Turn off the VPN on the router without changing the connection setup, and repeat the test.
  3. Compare the two results and move to the relevant branch below.

Strict appears only through the VPN

  1. Look for a NAT setting for the server at your VPN provider. According to NAT Checker, Moderate NAT on Proton VPN Plus disables random port mappings on the server. The mode can be enabled in the desktop app or in a supported router profile.
  2. If an open port is needed, enable forwarding through the tunnel on the provider's side. According to VPNMine, without provider support this cannot be fixed properly.

Strict persists without the VPN

  1. Check whether there is a second router in the chain, for example your own router behind the provider's router.
  2. Compare the WAN address in the router panel with the address shown by an IP checking website. If the addresses do not match, CGNAT is likely (a shared address at the provider). Confirm this with your provider.
  3. If CGNAT is confirmed, request a public IP address or use a VPN with NAT that can be opened. According to NAT Checker, router configuration behind CGNAT does not open NAT.

Check the result on the console

According to VPNMine, Strict NAT slows down matchmaking and routes voice chat through a relay. Sometimes a game refuses to create a lobby. NAT Checker considers Moderate sufficient for group chats and most matches. Open is needed if you host lobbies or play P2P games with players who have Strict.

  • On a PS5, run the internet connection test, then check the group chat and multiplayer.
  • On an Xbox, run the built-in network test and look at the NAT type.
  • If it shows Moderate and the chat works, change nothing. If you host games, you need forwarding through the tunnel.

An example. After enabling a VPN on the router, an Xbox shows Strict, and without the VPN it shows Moderate. The owner enables the server NAT mode in the router configuration that their provider supports. A repeat test shows Moderate, and the group chat works again.

CitadelVPN: keys for routers on the MAX plan

See also

Sources used